World cup referees
-
What do u pple think of these world cup referees? i think they anyhow flash out the yellow cards on most occassion..dunno is it due to the pressure fifa gave to cramp down any fouls or to protect those so called star players..the worst referee i witness till now is the switzerland-france match..he booked the swiss player for not listening to him and kick the ball out when one of the france player is injured outside the pitch...
I personally thot this is ridiculous decision..how come a ref forced a player to be sportmanship? if the swiss doesnt kick the ball out for the inj for treatment..he will only be booed for unsporting likes..but to caution him? i was amazed!! Look, the player is already outside the pitch and he can receive the treatment from the medics, y the hell the opposition need to kick the ball out to stop play? he doesnt need to be stretched off or permission for the medics to enter the field so y the booking?
The Holland-Ivory Coast oso got similar situation where twice the player inj outside the field..but the ref din stop play..so y the double standard? Some of the red cards given were rather harsh..the red card on the ukraine player oso another incident..the ghanian player booked for kicking the penalty b4 the ref blow his whistle..seems like referees nowadays dun give warning..book whenever there is any physical contact or mischieve..is there a need? not only they slow the pace of the game..it affects the players too..in my opionon, all teams now played to the world cup standard in every match..but its the ref who are the let downs of this tournament..sad to see the standard of football rise only to give in to the sub standard of refereeing... -
fifa asked them to clamp down on fouls one la..to allow teams like brazil and argentina to show their stuff..reported before..
-
all tis is done for the good of football
-
the fans really cb also, the player already injured out of playing field, can received still wanna kpkb that the ball is not kicked out of play.
-
Originally posted by Iolo:
France Vs USA
[b]What do u pple think of these world cup referees? i think they anyhow flash out the yellow cards on most occassion..
[b]
Red Card for both sides.
Oh yeh i think the refs are buyas to the Iranians... foul them so many times on their latest match against i forgot what countary....
No one is perfect, not even the refs are. Just let them decide.... -
and also because we are quite used to epl where more physical play is allowed ba..
-
i find it a good thing. otherwise the players over react to certain decisions made by the ref. i think sometimes the players have to learn to respect the refs' decisions...
-
June 19, 2006
Rank Top Rated Referees Rating
1 Graham Poll 7.6
2 Shamsul Maidin 7.3
3 Mark Alexander Shield 7.1
4 Roberto Rosetti 7.0
5 Horacio Elizondo 6.7
6 Toru Kamikawa 6.7
7 Armando Archundia 6.6
8 Coffi Codjia 6.6
9 Luis Medina Cantalejo 6.6
10 Lubos Michel 6.5 -
i think you would make a better referee than the referees that were chosen by the global football organizations, that make a living out of professional football and spent their lives around football. thank you, have a nice dayOriginally posted by Iolo:What do u pple think of these world cup referees? i think they anyhow flash out the yellow cards on most occassion..dunno is it due to the pressure fifa gave to cramp down any fouls or to protect those so called star players..the worst referee i witness till now is the switzerland-france match..he booked the swiss player for not listening to him and kick the ball out when one of the france player is injured outside the pitch...
I personally thot this is ridiculous decision..how come a ref forced a player to be sportmanship? if the swiss doesnt kick the ball out for the inj for treatment..he will only be booed for unsporting likes..but to caution him? i was amazed!! Look, the player is already outside the pitch and he can receive the treatment from the medics, y the hell the opposition need to kick the ball out to stop play? he doesnt need to be stretched off or permission for the medics to enter the field so y the booking?
The Holland-Ivory Coast oso got similar situation where twice the player inj outside the field..but the ref din stop play..so y the double standard? Some of the red cards given were rather harsh..the red card on the ukraine player oso another incident..the ghanian player booked for kicking the penalty b4 the ref blow his whistle..seems like referees nowadays dun give warning..book whenever there is any physical contact or mischieve..is there a need? not only they slow the pace of the game..it affects the players too..in my opionon, all teams now played to the world cup standard in every match..but its the ref who are the let downs of this tournament..sad to see the standard of football rise only to give in to the sub standard of refereeing... -
Lol now the refs are playing a seperate game hahaOriginally posted by LazerLordz:June 19, 2006
Rank Top Rated Referees Rating
1 Graham Poll 7.6
2 Shamsul Maidin 7.3
3 Mark Alexander Shield 7.1
4 Roberto Rosetti 7.0
5 Horacio Elizondo 6.7
6 Toru Kamikawa 6.7
7 Armando Archundia 6.6
8 Coffi Codjia 6.6
9 Luis Medina Cantalejo 6.6
10 Lubos Michel 6.5 -
Originally posted by coffeeortea:i think you would make a better referee than the referees that were chosen by the global football organizations, that make a living out of professional football and spent their lives around football. thank you, have a nice day
-
i only noe robben's yellow card for diving was spot-on! yeah! down wif cheaters!
-
Well, Shamsul is still no.2Originally posted by sand king:Lol now the refs are playing a seperate game haha -
he is the singaporean ref right?Originally posted by LazerLordz:Well, Shamsul is still no.2 -
That is to protect players who play beautiful football. Unless you like to watch only stamina, pace and physical style of play. Or you like to watch Robbie Savage style rather than a Ronaldinho style?Originally posted by Iolo:What do u pple think of these world cup referees? i think they anyhow flash out the yellow cards on most occassion..dunno is it due to the pressure fifa gave to cramp down any fouls or to protect those so called star players..the worst referee i witness till now is the switzerland-france match..he booked the swiss player for not listening to him and kick the ball out when one of the france player is injured outside the pitch...
I personally thot this is ridiculous decision..how come a ref forced a player to be sportmanship? if the swiss doesnt kick the ball out for the inj for treatment..he will only be booed for unsporting likes..but to caution him? i was amazed!! Look, the player is already outside the pitch and he can receive the treatment from the medics, y the hell the opposition need to kick the ball out to stop play? he doesnt need to be stretched off or permission for the medics to enter the field so y the booking?
The Holland-Ivory Coast oso got similar situation where twice the player inj outside the field..but the ref din stop play..so y the double standard? Some of the red cards given were rather harsh..the red card on the ukraine player oso another incident..the ghanian player booked for kicking the penalty b4 the ref blow his whistle..seems like referees nowadays dun give warning..book whenever there is any physical contact or mischieve..is there a need? not only they slow the pace of the game..it affects the players too..in my opionon, all teams now played to the world cup standard in every match..but its the ref who are the let downs of this tournament..sad to see the standard of football rise only to give in to the sub standard of refereeing...
If yes, watch ruby.
-
Where do these rankings come from? By what criteria are they ranked?Originally posted by LazerLordz:June 19, 2006
Rank Top Rated Referees Rating
1 Graham Poll 7.6
2 Shamsul Maidin 7.3
3 Mark Alexander Shield 7.1
4 Roberto Rosetti 7.0
5 Horacio Elizondo 6.7
6 Toru Kamikawa 6.7
7 Armando Archundia 6.6
8 Coffi Codjia 6.6
9 Luis Medina Cantalejo 6.6
10 Lubos Michel 6.5 -
ESPN Soccernet.Originally posted by dakkon_blackblade:Where do these rankings come from? By what criteria are they ranked? -
Originally posted by coffeeortea:
ah..thats not true..they have full time jobs outside...btw..i think u need to read more b4 commenting..u think i thot who confirm?
i think you would make a better referee than the referees that were chosen by the global football organizations, [b]that make a living out of professional football and spent their lives around football. thank you, have a nice day -
did i commented anything on style? hmm..anyway wat does watching a ruby has to do with world cupOriginally posted by JusStatic:That is to protect players who play beautiful football. Unless you like to watch only stamina, pace and physical style of play. Or you like to watch Robbie Savage style rather than a Ronaldinho style?
If yes, watch ruby.
-
Originally posted by Iolo:
You still dont get what I mean. Never mind then
did i commented anything on style? hmm..anyway wat does watching a [b]ruby has to do with world cup [/b] -
[quote]Originally posted by Iolo:
ah..thats not true..they have full time jobs outside...btw..i think u need to read more b4 commenting..u think i thot who confirm?[/quote
stop that primary school "you think i thot who confirm" it is so passe, and it sounds like some youngin primary 1 girl that would say something like that. i need to read more before commenting? you need to understand that you dont make a living out of soccer, unlike them. its no use arguing, i already said that you are more experienced than the professional referees, you are the king, you are the soccer god, you are the god of referees. now sit on your throne and bask in your professionalism in being a referee for soccer matches. -
This year's referee good , very good . No controversy ...... very much to our likings .
fair is the word . -
what is the next match Shamsul Maidin will be ref?
-
the ref for the game between italy and us really fcuked up.
-
Hell yeh! 3 red 3 yellows 47 fouls... retardOriginally posted by used:the ref for the game between italy and us really fcuked up.