Twenty months after his shock selection for England's World Cup squad, Theo Walcott continues to divide opinions easier than he splits opposing defences.On the second anniversary of his £12m transfer to Arsenal last weekend, his former Southampton manager George Burley insisted he "should have stayed here at least another year".
And even Arsene Wenger admitted the player, who only turns 19 in March, has been "troubled" and "feels under pressure".
His fluky equaliser in the first leg was his first and only goal in domestic action this campaign. And the No.32 he wears on his back is still more than the 24 first-teams starts he has made for Arsenal.
Nicklas Bendtner, his strike partner last night, has scored more goals - five - since returning from his loan spell at Birmingham last season than Walcott's four in his Arsenal career.
A semi-final at the home of their local rivals in front of the new England manager was a chance for Walcott to show he can deliver on the big stage.
But instead, with his Arsenal side badly needing inspiration, he fluffed his lines. The 18-year-old was pushed around by Spurs centre-backs Ledley King and Michael Dawson like two bullies picking on a little boy on his first day at a new school. Even Lee Young-Pyo seemed to tower over him.
Even before the break the frustrated Arsenal fans were calling for the introduction of the physical presence of Emmanuel Adebayor from the bench. And when the Togo striker did make a belated appearance on 65 minutes, it was Walcott who made way. And within seconds, Adebayor had found the back of the net.
Wenger said of Walcott at the weekend: "He will get to where I expect him to be, but at the moment he is not." The wait goes on.