North-South Line train services delayed
-
http://forums.hardwarezone.com/showpost.php?p=22571556&postcount=135Originally posted by oxford mushroom:Exposed as fake already
http://www.mycarforum.com/forum/Yishun_Mrt_Incident_P1767170/#1767170
How to justify the videos are not fake?
1. Actors that run away.
How to gather actors and runaway in a MRT scene. Who are so free to do that?
Even they are paid to act the scene, anybody with the right frame of mind will do that?
Don't they have the pea-brained to think of the consequences of the law?
2. Angle of the shoot
Looking at both videos, all are shot at a high angle.
Unless you are the cleaner or maintenace staff of the MRT, only then you can carry the ladder and shoot the scene with your handphone camera.
Even you managed to get a friend to carry you up to shoot. It can't be go unnoticed by other people or the eyes of the CCTV.
3. Time of the shoot
Yishun video happened in the morning and Admiralty happened in noon time.
During these hours, there are bound to have crowds. Who so free go and make a fake video without letting other people recognise?
and lastly, i really can't figure out anybody really darn free to make a suicide video?
http://forums.hardwarezone.com/showpost.php?p=22570748&postcount=101 -
Exactly.. and the fella use shadows as part of his argument....
so why when the people run away.. their shadows follow them as well... and not to mention... the trains shadow as well......
besides... u can definitely see the the person who jumps shadow as well...
the fella is book smart.. but not street smart imo.. -
plenty of losers out there learning to use overlays and video editing softwareOriginally posted by ^tamago^:[url]i really can't figure out anybody really darn free to make a suicide video?
http://forums.hardwarezone.com/showpost.php?p=22570748&postcount=101
-
is that all u can offer?Originally posted by oxford mushroom:plenty of losers out that learning to use overlays and photoshop -
cos' that's all there is to it...Originally posted by ^tamago^:is that all u can offer?
Lee Wei Ling is right about Singaporeans being easily conned. -
Are you a fellow Singaporean or an MIW elite to badmouth us?Originally posted by oxford mushroom:cos' that's all there is to it...
Lee Wei Ling is right about Singaporeans being easily conned.
It is clear you are psycho-ing the public cos ur "boss" gave u the guidelines to do so. -
One thing about the videos I noticed, they are shot at quite a high angle. Unless the idiot(s) who shot it are tall, have a ladder or whatever freak reason, I somehow don't believe is real in some ways.
Yishun video happened in the morning and Admiralty happened in noon time.
Hmm... Yishun one happened a tad too early. It's slightly before 7am, and the station isn't too crowded. Admiralty one not sure.
During these hours, there are bound to have crowds. Who so free go and make a fake video without letting other people recognise?
The timing of the video might also be a problem. Not willing to say more, because it's after all a video, and something called parallax error.
Yishun video... where on earth did the man pop from? While it's true he fell, can't see him from anywhere.
-
so its real or fake?!?!?!
-
Too many questions and no answers. I have doubts, but the Yishun one is quite convincing.
-
So many ppl wants the authorities to come out and tell you all: Oh, Its real. Oh its fake.Originally posted by Y_Shun:so its real or fake?!?!?!
Use ur common sense when watching the clips. -
Wait long long for them to say. Not unless we hack in...Originally posted by Manager433:So many ppl wants the authorities to come out and tell you all: Oh, Its real. Oh its fake.
Use ur common sense when watching the clips.
-
I got no comments on this.
-
For the Yishun one, I wonder why the staff and other passengers didn't notice a person going down to the track and hinding under the platform...
And for the Admiralty one, it seems almost real...but I still doubt it coz the action of the boy looks quite "perfect"...
Last but not least...there were no blood, no scream and no strange voice,
which I had seen and listen in an accident many years ago... -
Looks like the first person who upload those clips found.
Bingo! Lets get him! -
the person:
name known
23-year-old
lives at taman jurong, address known
served his NS in SPF, ORD in 2005 -
Check this out, SMRT has confirmed that the video is a footage is of the actual incident.
http://news.asiaone.com.sg/st/st_20070226_94669.html -
Confirm that Yishun video is real, then Admiralty one? Somebody faked it?
-
No sure why people would want to jump down to the track
-
Not very sure about the Admiralty yet, I have not seen the video yet, anyone got it? But for people to fake the video, means their ass are itch to be in jail.Originally posted by ndmmxiaomayi:Confirm that Yishun video is real, then Admiralty one? Somebody faked it? -
Video kena removed due to Violation
The part of the clip and details still there as at 1930, but if you clicked it, it tells you it has been deleted due to violation of reg -
I did mention somewhere that not only smrt got the tape. LTA and MIB also did. So why die die people suspect ish smrt staff who record it?
Anyway, suspect identify from a blog. I strongly believed this blog started it all. Go get him! -
good luck to the person who spreaded the videos...
-
-
Hmm... Does anyone have the flv/video file of the Admiralty one?
-
Probe into video leaks of MRT accidents
Leong Wee Keat
weekeat@mediacorp.com.sg
THERE were no signs of blood, but the scenes still made viewers flinch.
Two separate videos of individuals being run over by MRT trains are making the rounds among Singapore's online community.
Even as the clips were removed from popular video hosting websites YouTube and Metacafe yesterday, they quickly resurfaced on other similar sites.
The SMRT confirmed yesterday that both clips were copies of its closed circuit television (CCTV) footage that had captured the two men being hit by trains at Yishun (picture) and Admiralty MRT stations last December.
An SMRT spokesman said that investigations were underway to determine how these unauthorised copies got into the public domain.
"If any person is found responsible, appropriate disciplinary action will be taken," she said.
"At SMRT, we are reviewing our processes to ensure strict adherence to the instructions and procedures in place to control access to such material."
The first video, a 40-second clip, surfaced on the Internet earlier this month. It shows a man being hit by a train at Yishun Station on Dec 5.
The second, lasting 18 seconds, appeared online later, portraying another man being struck by a train at Admiralty Station on Dec 2.
SMRT is working with the Police and the Land Transport Authority to investigate how copies of the CCTV footage got online.
The public transport operator has also written to another site that contains such material to remove the videos.
The SMRT spokesman added: "With regard to the online circulation and posting of these videos, we would like to advise members of the public not to circulate them as they are unauthorised copies and are also distasteful and disrespectful."