The Greatest Rock Band

• Hellraiza

  13 Sep 06, 16:32

  Originally posted by monoslayer:

  IHMO, keane, oasis, beatles, coldplay..

  fully agree
• Kuali Baba

  13 Sep 06, 18:08

  IMO the Beatles is definitely a pop group. Maybe Keane and Coldplay are too soft for ye?
• Hellraiza

  13 Sep 06, 18:14

  Originally posted by Kuali Baba:

  IMO the Beatles is definitely a pop group. Maybe Keane and Coldplay are too soft for ye?

  They don't have that rock sound and attitude....you compare keane with...let's say....AC/DC.
• Master -_-

  13 Sep 06, 18:15

  Wings
  Cream
  Judas Priest
  
  
• monoslayer

  13 Sep 06, 23:04

  Originally posted by Kuali Baba:

  IMO the Beatles is definitely a pop group. Maybe Keane and Coldplay are too soft for ye?

  keane dun even have a guitarist
• Xtrider

  13 Sep 06, 23:53

  red hot chilli peppers
  greenday
  guns and roses
• trendz

  13 Sep 06, 23:59

  Originally posted by stellazio:

  oasis can consider rock meh?

  isn't oasis ol' sch?
• fudgester

  14 Sep 06, 00:11

  Originally posted by Hellraiza:

  They don't have that rock sound and attitude....you compare keane with...let's say....AC/DC.

  Keane is classified under Piano Rock.
  
  Coldplay is Alternative Rock.
  
  In the end, they're both rock.
• monoslayer

  14 Sep 06, 00:15

  Originally posted by fudgester:

  Keane is classified under Piano Rock.
  
  Coldplay is Alternative Rock.
  
  In the end, they're both rock.

  ok. since tis is how u define "Rock"..
• Xtrider

  14 Sep 06, 00:23

  Originally posted by fudgester:

  Keane is classified under Piano Rock.
  
  Coldplay is Alternative Rock.
  
  In the end, they're both rock.

  got such thing as piano rock meh??
• monoslayer

  14 Sep 06, 00:33

  Originally posted by Xtrider:

  got such thing as piano rock meh??

  piano rock sometimes referred to as piano pop, is a term for a style of music that is based around the piano, and sometimes around piano-related instruments, such as the Fender Rhodes, the Wurlitzer electric piano, and keyboard-based synthesizers.
  
  Unlike the classic rock combination of lead guitar, bass guitar, drums, and vocals, piano rock puts the pianist front and center. Traditionally, piano rock has not been as prevalent as classic rock. However, modern bands such as Ben Folds Five, Keane and Coldplay, and solo artists such as Fiona Apple, Tori Amos and Rufus Wainwright, have heavily featured keyboard instruments in their songs.
  
  
• Gedanken

  14 Sep 06, 00:37

  Where the devil is Springsteen and the E Street Band?! How could you have a "greatest rock" list without The Boss? What happened to Led Zepplin, the Eagles, Steppenwolf, Van Halen, Joan Jett and the Blackhearts, Meat Loaf, Journey, ZZ Top and the Alan Parsons Project?
  
  I swear, kids these days ...
• Gedanken

  14 Sep 06, 00:39

  Originally posted by monoslayer:

  piano rock sometimes referred to as piano pop, is a term for a style of music that is based around the piano, and sometimes around piano-related instruments, such as the Fender Rhodes, the Wurlitzer electric piano, and keyboard-based synthesizers.
  
  Unlike the classic rock combination of lead guitar, bass guitar, drums, and vocals, piano rock puts the pianist front and center. Traditionally, piano rock has not been as prevalent as classic rock. However, modern bands such as Ben Folds Five, Keane and Coldplay, and solo artists such as Fiona Apple, Tori Amos and Rufus Wainwright, have heavily featured keyboard instruments in their songs.
  
  

  Nuh uh. Sorry, man - no axe, no rock. Simple as that.
• Xtrider

  14 Sep 06, 00:40

  Originally posted by monoslayer:

  piano rock sometimes referred to as piano pop, is a term for a style of music that is based around the piano, and sometimes around piano-related instruments, such as the Fender Rhodes, the Wurlitzer electric piano, and keyboard-based synthesizers.
  
  Unlike the classic rock combination of lead guitar, bass guitar, drums, and vocals, piano rock puts the pianist front and center. Traditionally, piano rock has not been as prevalent as classic rock. However, modern bands such as Ben Folds Five, Keane and Coldplay, and solo artists such as Fiona Apple, Tori Amos and Rufus Wainwright, have heavily featured keyboard instruments in their songs.
  
  

  icic...still trying to discover rock on my own after so many yrs...most of my frens listen to cheena pop... then emo and alternative?
• monoslayer

  14 Sep 06, 00:45

  Originally posted by Gedanken:

  Nuh uh. Sorry, man - no axe, no rock. Simple as that.

  Nuh uh. Sorry, dude. dun tell me, tell TS.
• Gedanken

  14 Sep 06, 00:46

  TS?
• monoslayer

  14 Sep 06, 00:47

  Originally posted by Gedanken:

  TS?

  TS = threadstarter
• Gedanken

  14 Sep 06, 00:52

  Well, I've said it once and I'll say it again. No axe, no rock. Keyboards, synthesizers and any electronic crap that makes an emphysemic cat with laryngitis being boiled sound good is pop, house, techno, emo, elmo, Eno, anything, but not rock.
• Hellraiza

  15 Sep 06, 09:19

  Originally posted by Gedanken:

  Nuh uh. Sorry, man - no axe, no rock. Simple as that.

  You said it man.
• kikq

  16 Sep 06, 06:19

  vote for bon jovi ppl
• Kuali Baba

  16 Sep 06, 13:44

  Originally posted by Gedanken:

  ...and the Alan Parsons Project?

  "I am the eye in the sky, looking at you...?"
  
  I did offer everyone a chance to put down whoever they think are the greatest rock bands, and the list reflects that. We need more people and more votes.
• The man who was death

  24 Sep 06, 20:43

  Scorpions
  Metallica
  The wallflowers
  
  next time got poll post in my forum
• <Precious>

  27 Sep 06, 10:16

  U2 for me!
• Kuali Baba

  6 Oct 06, 20:17

  I guess we have a winner that's an undisputed rock band?
• PointBlue

  6 Oct 06, 20:20

  coldplay
  PINK FLOYD
  RADIOHEAD